Dental Implants vs Dentures: What Patients Need to Know — Expert Insight from Implant Dentist David Gwyer

Introduction

Losing natural teeth can significantly affect speech, comfort, chewing, confidence, and oral health. For decades, traditional dentures were the only option available. Today, however, dental implants provide a more predictable, stable, and long-lasting solution. As an implant-focused dentist, David Gwyer has treated hundreds of patients across Ireland and the UK who wanted to understand the key differences between dentures and implants before making a decision.

This comprehensive guide explains how dental implants compare to dentures in function, comfort, durability, oral health impact, cost, and long-term satisfaction — using a tone that is professional, patient-friendly, and suited to a premium dental service.

1. How Dental Implants Work vs Dentures

Dental Implants

Dental implants are small titanium or zirconia posts inserted into the jawbone. They integrate with the bone and act as artificial roots, supporting crowns, bridges, or full arches of teeth. They feel and function like natural teeth.

Dentures

Dentures are removable acrylic prostheses that sit on top of the gums. Some require adhesive. Others may be stabilised by implants (implant-retained dentures).

2. Comfort and Everyday Function

Implants: The Closest Thing to Natural Teeth

Implants provide unmatched comfort because they:

• Do not move

• Do not rub the gums

• Restore natural chewing power

• Preserve bone and facial structure

Patients often report forgetting that the teeth are not natural.

Dentures: Can Feel Bulky or Unstable

Traditional dentures:

• May move when eating or speaking

• Can feel bulky or loose

• Cover the palate (upper denture)

• Can cause sore spots on the gums

Many patients adapt well to dentures, but those who struggle often seek implant solutions.

3. Appearance and Confidence

Implants Provide a Natural, Fixed Aesthetic

Implant-supported teeth are customised in shape and colour to match the patient. They maintain facial structure, preventing a sunken look that often occurs as bone shrinks.

Dentures Can Look Natural — But May Lack Support

Good dentures can look excellent, but:

• They provide no bone support

• They may slip during conversation

• Appearance can deteriorate as bone changes beneath them

Implants offer better long-term aesthetics.

4. Eating and Chewing Ability

Implants Allow Strong, Confident Chewing

Implants restore:

• 80–100% of natural bite force

• The ability to eat tougher foods

• Full enjoyment of meals

As David Gwyer often explains to his implant patients:

“Stable teeth transform not only your smile but how you live day to day.”

Dentures Limit Chewing Power

Dentures typically restore:

• 20–30% of chewing ability

• Difficulty with meats, crunchy foods, or sticky foods

• Risk of food getting underneath the denture

This is one of the main reasons denture wearers transition to implants.

5. Speech and Pronunciation

Implants Support Clear, Natural Speech

Because implants are fixed, patients avoid:

• Clicking sounds

• Shifting teeth

• Lisping

Dentures Can Affect Speech

Especially new or loose dentures. Patients often need time to adjust.

6. Bone Health and Facial Appearance

Implants Preserve Bone

Implants stimulate the jawbone, preventing bone loss. They maintain:

• Facial structure

• Lip support

• Cheek fullness — avoiding a prematurely aged appearance

• 
  

Dentures Accelerate Bone Loss

Without roots, the bone gradually shrinks — a process called resorption.

This can cause:

• Loosening of dentures

• Collapsed facial profile

• Changes in bite and appearance

Implants are the only replacement that stops this process.

7. Maintenance Requirements

Implants

• Brush and floss like natural teeth

• Regular dental hygiene visits

• No adhesives

• Long-term stability

Dentures

• Remove daily

• Clean overnight

• Use adhesive if loose

• Require periodic relining or full replacement due to bone changes

Implants generally require less maintenance long-term.

8. Longevity and Value

Implants Can Last a Lifetime

Implant posts often last decades with good care. Crowns may need replacing every 10–15 years.

Dentures Require Replacement

Typically every 5–8 years due to:

• Wear

• Bone loss

• Fit changes

When comparing long-term cost, implants often represent better value.

9. Cost Factors & Affordability

Implants

Higher initial cost, but:

• Long lifespan

• Better quality of life

• Less ongoing maintenance

  
  

Dentures

Lower upfront cost, but:

• Frequent adjustments/replacements

• Possible need for adhesives

• Reduced comfort and chewing

Patients increasingly choose implants for their life-changing benefits.

10. Who Is Best Suited for Each Option?

Best Candidates for Implants

• Patients seeking stability

• Those who dislike dentures

• Patients with adequate bone (or eligible for grafting)

• Patients wanting the best long-term investment

• 
  

Best Candidates for Dentures

• Patients needing a low-cost temporary solution

• Individuals unable to undergo surgery (rare)

• Patients waiting for bone graft healing before implants

  
  

11. Expert Perspective from David Gwyer

As an implant-focused dentist, David Gwyer sees patterns across thousands of cases:

“Most patients who switch from dentures to implants tell me the same thing — they wish they had done it years earlier. The confidence, the comfort, the ability to eat properly… it’s completely transformative.”

Conclusion

Dental implants and dentures both serve important roles, but they offer very different experiences. Implants provide superior comfort, stability, appearance, and long-term oral health benefits. For patients seeking a premium, reliable, life-enhancing solution, implants consistently outperform traditional dentures.